Self Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing: Which One is for You?


Was chatting at a networking event with an author who is working on her first book. She mentioned that she had decided she was going to go the traditional publishing route. I then asked her this question: Do you have any contacts in the traditional publishing industry? Answer? No. So I had to be the bearer of the bad news that it could take years to achieve that... if she would be able to achieve it at all.

Of course, we've all heard of success stories of authors whose first books have burst onto the publishing landscape, seemingly "overnight." But the hard truth is that "overnight" is more likely to be "over-years" since getting to that point may have taken thousands of rejection letters and heartache. And that's on top of the years it may have taken to write the thing.

Would I automatically recommend that all novice authors default to a self publishing model for their first books? Absolutely not! And if having a book published by one of the traditional publishing houses is a goal, then stay true to your dream until you achieve it.

But here's a quick rundown of questions to ask yourself if you're weighing the benefits of self publishing versus traditional publishing:

1. What contacts do you have that can introduce you to publishing houses?

In today's publishing world, publishers may have a team of acquisition (or development) editors who evaluate the potential for authors and books. If you don't have a networking contact who can introduce you to the acquisition personnel at publishers, then you may want to explore the possibility of hiring an agent to represent you. Agents will take a cut of your royalties for representing you. Be aware, too, that getting an agent might be as tough as getting the attention of a publishing house direct. Both agents and publishers can be ruthless in evaluating the market viability of authors and books (as they should be). So if you don't have the network, be prepared for what I'm going to ask in Question 2.


2. How equipped are you emotionally to handle rejection, possibly for an extended period of time?

If you're the sort of person who gets easily bummed out when someone rejects you or your work, pursuing a traditional publishing contract will be a very challenging endeavor. It could take hundreds, even thousands, of sales pitch letters to even get considered, much less get a contract. (I know some writers are already cringing at the word "sales.") But if you have the emotional fortitude to keep on keeping on when it comes to pitching publishers, then it might be worth considering the traditional publishing route if you desire it.

Note, though, that if you go the self publishing route to avoid the rejection by a traditional publishing house, you also need to be ready for rejection by the ultimate critics: Your readers.

3. What are your expectations in terms of earnings per book?

If you're looking to get higher earnings per book, self publishing can usually provide them. Why? Because after all the layers and players of the traditional publishing process get paid—editors, printers, warehouses, distributors, etc.—there is usually little left over to pay author royalties. Granted, traditionally published authors could make more per book than self published authors if advances are considered.

Remember that an advance under a traditional contract is paid against future anticipated royalties. Keep in mind, too, that some contracts stipulate that the publisher could ask for an advance back if the book doesn't sell as expected. Whether a publisher exercises that right or not varies. But be aware that under some contracts it's a possibility.


4. How soon do you want to publish?

If your plan is to have your book in the marketplace within months, or even the coming year, self publishing is usually the quickest route. Securing a traditional publishing contract could take years to accomplish... and it may never happen. So what opportunities for reaching your market, speaking engagements and more are you sacrificing to put a traditional publisher's badge of honor on your work?

Even if you do secure a lucrative traditional publishing contract in a reasonable amount of time, it can take quite a while to get your manuscript into the market due to the time it takes to put your manuscript through editing, layout, proofing, printing, shipping and distribution.

5. Do you want to repurpose your work in the future?

This is a big issue! Some traditional publishing contracts may not allow authors to use or repurpose the material from their books. No grabbing a chapter to publish on a blog! No copying bits and pieces in another book! Authors with these restrictions in their contracts may not be able to republish or repurpose their manuscripts, reducing revenue opportunities. Some contracts may even prevent these authors from publishing future works elsewhere or self publishing, except under certain conditions. Get legal help to review a publishing contract before signing! Know your rights!

Self publishing can allow you greater freedom to repurpose and republish material. However, avoid using material you've created for others, such as guest blog posts or client work. In those cases, too, know what rights you're giving away when you collaborate with others. Again, an attorney familiar with publishing law can provide needed insight for your situation.


6. What amount of book marketing are you willing to do personally?

This is almost a trick question. When you self publish your book, you are totally responsible for the marketing and promotion of your work. That's a given. But many traditionally published authors are surprised to discover that after a publisher puts their books on the market, there may be very little marketing support provided! So you will be doing your own book marketing either way. However, a traditional publisher may be able to offer your book in places where self published works may rarely be considered.

7. What would you hope to accomplish by going with the traditional publishing route?

In a podcast I did with a good author friend of mine who was traditionally published, she chose the traditional route because of the prestige factor that it brought to her and to her business. That certainly would be a reason to explore the traditional route regardless of the uphill battle it might be.


8. What is the market value that you bring to a traditional publisher?

Books have been written about every imaginable topic on this planet. Check your ego at the door because there are probably hundreds or thousands of books just like yours out there. What unique market value do you and your book provide? If you don't have that story straight, expect quick rejection. Just because it's your personal goal to get your book done through a publishing house is irrelevant. Publishers want a book that will make sales... lots of sales. If you can't demonstrate the market value or potential sales, you're too high of a risk and could be added to a publisher's reject pile.

Realize, too, that many publishers may not be able to properly assess the market for your book, especially in some smaller niche markets. You may have more expert experience and knowledge of that market than some publishers do. Smaller niche markets also may not be able to produce the sales results a publisher may need or want.

It's a Catch-22. You need to be unique enough to provide value to a publisher, but if you're too unique, a publisher will have trouble assessing the marketability of your work. So if you're determined to get your niche market work published, self publishing may ultimately be the best route.

For either route, know your market and the value you bring to it.

9. How do you hope your book will be sold?

Notice that I didn't ask if you were hoping to see your book in bookstores. Even if you go with the traditional publishing route, it is no guarantee that your book will be on the shelves in your local retail bookstore.

As well, if you plan to do back of the room sales at events, as a traditionally published author, you may have to purchase copies of your book at retail to resell to your audiences. Yes, at retail! Translation: You'll make little or no money.

With self publishing you do have more control over when, where, how and for how much your book is sold.

Disclaimer: Both the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparation of this information. No representations or warranties for its contents, either expressed or implied, are offered or allowed and both parties disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for your particular purpose. The advice and strategies presented herein may not be suitable for you, your situation or business. Consult with a professional advisor where and when appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential or punitive, arising from or relating to your reliance on this information.

© 2016 Heidi Thorne

More by this Author

  • Book Signing Event Tips for Self Published Authors

    To celebrate and announce your self published book, you've taken a page from the traditional publishing playbook and want to host a book signing event. But that's quite a project! See what's involved.

  • Self Publishing Platforms Pros and Cons

    These days, many authors and independent publishers are turning to self publishing platforms to get their books to market. Learn what these platforms provide, as well as pros and cons.

  • Types of Book Binding

    How a book is printed and distributed can affect its sales, marketability and usability. Discover the most common types of book binding, as well as pros and cons of each for self publishing.

Comments 29 comments

lambservant profile image

lambservant 8 months ago from Pacific Northwest

Very good information. Do you have any articles on how to choose a self-publishing company? Or do you have any recommendations?

billybuc profile image

billybuc 8 months ago from Olympia, WA

I'm living this entire article, and you are, once again, right on with your information and recommendations. All writers would do well to read this realistic look at the publishing business.

Enjoy your day, Heidi!

FlourishAnyway profile image

FlourishAnyway 8 months ago from USA

Excellent advice and a reality check for many. Sharing!

jo miller profile image

jo miller 8 months ago from Tennessee

I'm in the middle of reading a very good book on self-publishing that is opening my eyes about this route. Your article just adds to this information. Thanks for the excellent advice.

sallybea profile image

sallybea 8 months ago from Norfolk

Telling it straight as it should be told, very interesting, will definitely return to do a little more reading. Thanks for sharing.

PegCole17 profile image

PegCole17 8 months ago from Dallas, Texas

Great advice and timely, too. I know of several authors who are trying to make this difficult decision.

AliciaC profile image

AliciaC 8 months ago from British Columbia, Canada

This is another excellent hub, Heidi. It contains some very useful advice for writers!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Thanks, AliciaC! Yep, writers need to know the publishing landscape before they dive in. Have a beautiful day!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi PegCole17! I think ALL authors go through this difficult decision at some point in their careers. Thanks for stopping by and chiming in! Cheers!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi sallybea! No sugarcoating here. :) Glad you found it helpful. Thanks for stopping by and commenting. Have a great day!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi jo miller! Indeed, when you start digging into the publishing world, it can be quite eye-opening. Glad you found the post helpful. Thanks for stopping by and have a great day!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Yep, FlourishAnyway, I always try to be Reality Check Central! :) Thanks for checking it out and have a wonderful day!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Indeed, billybuc, I knew you'd be able to relate. :) Thanks for the confirmation! Have a wonderful day! (We're still in deep freeze here in CHI.)

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 8 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi lambservant! I have done a hub on self publishing platforms which might be of help. Here's the link: I personally use Amazon Createspace and Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing. Both of them are really geared for DIY (do it yourself) publishing. They do have add-on services for editing, formatting, etc. for a fee. Other platforms may bundle those services into a package price. There are several platforms out there. Just make sure you know what you're getting before getting in. Thanks for asking! Hope this helps. Good luck with your publishing adventures!

lawrence01 profile image

lawrence01 7 months ago from Hamilton, New Zealand


When I came to HP writing and publishing a book wasn't really on the agenda (Okay I'll admit it was on the wish list but seemed such a daunting task) but after a year here I'm starting to enjoy the idea of actually publishing a novel or two and for me the best way is self publishing.

I signed up with CreateSpace a few days ago but the novel will be a while being written.

I'm serializing most of it here on HP under the titles "Sting of the Scorpion".

This is some really good advice about the whole area, thank you.


heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 7 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi Lawrence! I'm so glad to here that you've been encouraged to move forward with your self publishing... and that you've found HP as a way to help make that happen. I think you'll really enjoy using Createspace. Thank you for the update on your publishing adventures! Have a great day!

Larry Rankin profile image

Larry Rankin 7 months ago from Oklahoma

Great analysis.

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 7 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi Larry! Thanks for the kind words. Have a great weekend!

Robert Sacchi profile image

Robert Sacchi 6 months ago

An interesting article. It seems the chances of a new author, even if they write a great book, to get traditionally published is near zero. One aspect, and deterent, to self-publishing is the possibility of the author spending a lot of money and have nothing to show for it but a stack of unsold books.

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 6 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hello Robert! True, the chances of getting a book published these days through traditional routes is very small. Also true is that self publishing can end up with a lot of unsold books. Luckily, these days, self publishing platforms offer print on demand for print books and ebook publishing, which can help eliminate that investment in the "product." Best investments for self publishers are in getting editing help, design (if you don't use the free tools on the self publishing platform sites) and marketing. Thanks for adding your insight to the conversation! Have a great day!

Robert Sacchi profile image

Robert Sacchi 6 months ago

Thank you.

Mel Carriere profile image

Mel Carriere 6 months ago from San Diego California

Very useful tips. It's a difficult business, and only those with passion and a very strong will will rise to the top. The beauty of the modern world, however, means that authors with effort and persistence can get their voice across without relying on traditional publishing houses. Great hub!

lawrence01 profile image

lawrence01 6 months ago from Hamilton, New Zealand

Just to add to the debate about 'print on demand' I ordered a book from the US using a HP site. The book took two weeks (pretty good timeframe) and all the way Amazon kept me updated on where things were at.

The book itself worked out (even with shipping costs which you don't get in the US) $5 cheaper than I would expect to pay in a bookstore so why would I want to buy using the traditional method?

Just a few thoughts!


heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 6 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi Lawrence! Thanks for adding your experience to the conversation. Ain't it a wonderful world we have these days? :) Have a great day and weekend ahead!

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 6 months ago from Chicago Area Author

True that, Mel! I think the persistence piece is what many self and traditionally published authors often lack. What they forget is that this is a long-term investment. Case in point: I'm still making royalties off books I published years ago. Thank you so much for chiming in! Have a great evening and weekend ahead!

William E Edwards 5 months ago

I find it difficult to find a good reason to try an find a traditional publisher. Most of these guys are either irrelevant or are living in the past and still treat new authors like dirt. Once the marketing end is figured out, self publishing will overwhelm traditional publishing.

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 5 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hello William! I have to agree with you on not being interested in seeking out a traditional publisher. My books would be on hold forever if I waited for that! While that model still exists for large scale distribution, the self publishing model just continues to gain ground. Thanks for adding your perspective to the conversation! Have a great day!

Greensleeves Hubs profile image

Greensleeves Hubs 3 months ago from Essex, UK

Clearly Heidi, from this article and from others you have written, you have considerable knowledge of this and you present that knowledge in a straightforward, easy-to-read style, without being too absolutist about your advice.

I would love to get some work published in the future, but the whole process is very daunting for me, whichever way I choose to go - either the endless cycle of letters and confidence-sapping rejections, or the prospect of trying to fathom out publishing and marketing myself.

I shall bookmark this, so that if and when I finally feel able to take the plunge, I can hopefully make an educated assessment of the best way to go! Alun

heidithorne profile image

heidithorne 3 months ago from Chicago Area Author

Hi Alun (Greensleeves)! True, either path can be challenging and rewarding. While it might not seem so now, when the time is right for you to go forward, the right path to take will seem more obvious. It was that way for me. We'll look forward to hearing about your publishing adventures! Have a beautiful rest of the weekend!

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article