An Ideal Venue For Revenge: A Response by cam to The Coors Accident or Murder …Flash Fiction Mystery Challenge.

From the Hub of Shyron E. Shenko

My fellow Hubbers are challenged to write a solution to this mystery about a young man who dropped dead after downing a beer.

There are no rules other than my story cannot be changed, it is purposely left open-ended for you to write the next chapter and continue or end the story.

Author's Note

I have written the following flash fiction story in response to Shyron E. Shenko's specific challenge "To write a solution to the mystery." You can read Shyron's challenge along with the original story at The Coors Accident or Murder …Flash Fiction Mystery Challenge.

I have taken the challenge very literally in that I have only attempted to solve the suspicious death of Kyle Rutland by producing the motive, means and opportunity for the killing and the identity of the killer. Within the evidence and storyline provided by Shyron, there was a great deal of information that was not relevant to solving the crime. I left all of this material aside and dealt only with what lead me to what I believe is a plausible truth.

Following the end of the flash fiction story, I have included a section which shows what I considered to be true evidence which would lead to a solution for the killing of Kyle Rutland.


The Ideal Venue for Revenge

Beverly was busy in the kitchen of a house where she was hosting a community dinner. She stirred the barbecue sauce which simmered just as her anger had been simmering for years. Ever since that woman, Jess, had come around and dated all the available men, Beverly had been doing double time to make sure she invaded and sabotaged each of those relationships. She had even moved in with the woman for a few months just to keep an eye on who Jess was seeing.

But what had she gotten for her efforts? Pregnant. Now the child was a teenager, and Beverly resented the constant reminder of failed relationships.

Kyle, Beverly’s son, came into the kitchen with three friends hoping to get something to eat.

“Out of the kitchen. There will be food soon enough at the serving line. And stay away from the beer coolers. Those are for adults only.”

Beverly followed them, worrying about her son’s new passion for alcohol. When she got to the doorway she scanned the outdoor dining area. The band had set up and was playing the country song, Back in Baby’s Arms. She loathed love songs these days.

Her stomach burned with anger. She clenched her fists and fought back tears. She would be better off channeling all the passion into revenge than into shedding these pitiful tears.

Her eyes settled on a couple sitting at one of the tables, singing along with the band. No! it wasn’t possible that those two were back together. Watching them enjoy the song brought back all the bitterness that she had buried.

How could Jess even consider going out with Derek again? Beverly remembered how she had seduced Derek in to a lengthy relationship while he was dating Jess years before. The result of that fling was the alcohol craving fifteen year old named Kyle.

She went back to stirring the barbecue sauce along with her resentments and anger. Derek, Kyle and she could have been a happy family. But that woman, Jess, had been in the way. What did it matter that Jess had already been in a relationship with him. Beverly had seen the man she wanted and gone for it.

Her stomach burned with anger. She clenched her fists and fought back tears. She would be better off channeling all the passion into revenge than into shedding these pitiful tears.

She had thought of revenge before, had even gone so far as to get a bottle of pills that would do the job. This really is the ideal venue for revenge, isn’t it? Them together. Me watching from the kitchen with all the food and drink they will consume this night at my fingertips. It would feel so empowering to finally release years of emotional filth in one act of retribution.

It would feel so empowering to finally release years of emotional filth in one act of retribution.

She wiped her hands on a towel and went to her purse. The bottle was still buried at the bottom after all this time. Had the pills lost their potency? She’d use enough to make that concern irrelevant.

One by one, she opened the hydrocodone capsules and poured the crystals into the bottle of Coors beer. She counted the milligrams until she reached ninety, the lethal dose, and kept opening and pouring. The alcohol would make it even more deadly. She waited until the drug was completely dissolved in the beer and replaced the screw-on cap as tightly as she could.

Beverly carried the bottle out to the table and set it down behind Jess.

“Hey, where’s mine?” said Derek.

“You can go get yours from one of the ice chests,” she said. “Only the ladies get special treatment.”

Derek left to find the beer, and Jess turned around. The women’s eyes met and Beverly released all her fury into that gaze. Jess’s only response was a simple thank you.

Derek returned, popped the tab on his can and took a drink.

Beverly walked back toward the kitchen. Jess doesn’t even drink….Lucky Derek will get Jess’s Coors.

Hydrocodone Capsules


Derek and Jess turned their attention back to the band. Behind them, a teenage boy slipped over to their table and picked up the Coors bottle. He unscrewed the cap and tipped the bottle, taking several chugs before coming up for air. He screwed the cap back on and set the bottle on the table just as Jess turned her head.

Three other teens ran toward the one who had drank Jess’s beer, and he hurried to meet them. Before he could go far, he stopped and vomited, then fell face first into the grass.

A crowd gathered around the boy, and someone discovered he wasn’t breathing.

Beverly heard the commotion and ran outside. She saw her son lying on the ground and saw one of the other teens point at the bottle on Jess’s table.

“He just drank that bottle of beer,” said the teen.


“Instead of going to where Kyle lay, Beverly went to where Jess and Derek sat. “You gave your beer to my son?” She reached for the bottle, but stopped short. Two calls went out to the emergency services, but Beverly chose to wait where Jess and Derek were, rather than going to Kyle. She was very interested in the bottle he had drank from.

“I didn’t give him my beer,” said Jess. “He sneaked up behind me and drank from it before I realized he was there.” She brought a paper bag up from under the table and set it next to the other bottle. “This is the one he drank from,” she said to Beverly.

Beverly swung at the bottle in the paper bag to try and tip it over, but Jess grabbed it and pulled it away. Beverly lunged at her, but a police officer who had just arrived restrained her. “Give me that bottle.” But then she remember Kyle. The paramedics were lifting the boy into the ambulance. She tore away from the officer and ran, screaming for them to put him down. One of the paramedics stepped forward and whispered into her ear. She let out a wailing moan and collapsed, unconscious, onto the grass. Beverly had killed her own son.

Synopsis of the Evidence

In the information presented by Shyron E Shenko in the challenge, Jess had dated Derek, Mike and Brandon. Within that same framework of time, Beverly had dated Derek and Mike and had claimed to have had an affair with Jess’s husband at the time, Brandon.

The constant competition between these two women for the same men created bad feelings. Jess resented Beverly because it appeared that Beverly was always pursuing her men. Beverly resented Jess because Jess always seemed to get the men Beverly wanted.

In that time period, Beverly had gotten pregnant. After Brandon died, leaving Jess as his widow and heir, Beverly tried to prove that Brandon had been the father of her child, Kyle. Actually, Brandon and Beverly never had an affair, so he could not have been Kyle’s father. Instead, Beverly had been seeing Derek at the time she claimed she was seeing Brandon. Derek was the real father of Kyle.

When Jess and Derek came to the barbecue, Beverly was shocked to see them back together. She put poison into the coors bottle which conveniently came with a screw-on lid. She presented it as a beer for Jess, but Jess did not drink. Beverly would have known this since the two women had lived together for a period of time in LA. That knowledge was her cover. She knew that Jess would pass the beer on to Derek, Beverly’s intended target. She sought revenge against Derek for abandoning Kyle and her and because he had gone back to Jess. But Kyle, Beverly’s and Derek’s son, came along and took a drink of the poisoned beer.

Beverly was so concerned about the evidence of poison in the bottle that she showed more concern for it than she did for her son who lay dying in the grass. If convicted, I believe the death of Kyle would be for manslaughter. She might also be convicted of attempted murder in the first degree since she purchased the hydrocodone far in advance for the purpose of murdering Derek.

More by this Author

Comments 17 comments

bravewarrior profile image

bravewarrior 3 months ago from Central Florida

You did a great job of the challenge and making sense of the evidence, Chris. It's sad that Beverly's son had to die, although I don't think she mourned his death as much as she mourned getting caught in her devious deed.

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 3 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Deb, thanks for stopping by.....eight days ago. But the fact is, I just got the notification that you commented. I've been seeing this a lot. I'll pass it on to the HP staff.

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 3 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Larry and Ann, sorry I missed these comments. I do believe there is a glitch in the comments area. I'm finding lots of comments that I haven't responded to and I am normally very excited to respond. Thank you for stopping by and reading the story. Your presence here is appreciated.

Lawrence Hebb 3 months ago

Enjoyed this story Chris. It was good to see how you worked the story out and put the things together to give us a great tale.

Deb Hirt 4 months ago

Excellent story, Chris. Every time I think that you have outdone yourself, you always come up with something more.

annart profile image

annart 4 months ago from SW England

Having just read Shyron's challenge story, I came to the same conclusion as you regarding the poisoning but didn't think about Derek being the father. You've written a great story here and your list of evidence is watertight! Well done, Chris!


Larry Rankin profile image

Larry Rankin 4 months ago from Oklahoma

Very entertaining!

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 4 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Ruby, thanks for reading my response to Shyron's challenge. It's always fun to get inovolved in these challenges. Thanks for reading.

always exploring profile image

always exploring 4 months ago from Southern Illinois

Wow, you did a superb job of writing this challenge ending. The green eyed monster delivered the kill. How very sad....

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 4 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Eric, Thank you for that comment....very kind. And thanks for reading this story.

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 4 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Shyron, Thank you. I am always looking for a writing challenge, and this one was definitely challenging. The setup that you provided was excellent.

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 4 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

John, I appreciate the comment. I think the question was whether this should be considered an accident or murder. My answer is neither. She is guilty of manslaughter, at least in the way I have portrayed her in the story. Thanks for reading.

cam8510 profile image

cam8510 4 months ago from Columbus, Georgia until the end of November 2016. Author

Venkatachari M, Thank you for reading this story. I really enjoyed participating in the challenge.

Ericdierker profile image

Ericdierker 4 months ago from Spring Valley, CA. U.S.A.

What a twist of fate. You are a champion writer for sure. It is always a pleasure to read your work. Thank you.

Shyron E Shenko profile image

Shyron E Shenko 4 months ago

Oh "WOW"! Chris this is great, I am so pleased that you accepted my challenge, you did an awesome job.

Blessings my friend.

Jodah profile image

Jodah 4 months ago from Queensland Australia

A great job, Chris. This was a very believable ending to Shyron's story. I think you solved it perfectly.

Venkatachari M profile image

Venkatachari M 4 months ago from Hyderabad, India

Very thrilling and interesting. You met the challenge brilliantly and concluded it so beautifully unearthing the suspense.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    cam8510 profile image

    Chris Mills (cam8510)473 Followers
    208 Articles

    Chris has written more than 100 flash fiction/short stories.Working Vacation took 21st out of 6,700 in the 2016 Writer's Digest competition.

    Click to Rate This Article