Theme of Desire in Shakespeare's "Twelfth Night"
Literature often presents accurate representations of society. William Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” was written as a fictional play, but the characters and situations of the play offer keen observations of 16th century life. Desire is an emotion experienced by all people. Shakespeare presents the desires of the multiple characters in “Twelfth Night” to emphasize the societal limitations of the characters according to gender, social class, and birthright. Sixteenth century society’s social class system presents multiple barriers for obtaining desires. Shakespeare’s work depicts those barriers with poetic and raucous language.
Sixteenth Century Social Classes
The feudal society of Middle English times only slightly evolved in the 16th century. This was considered the Tudor times. Life was governed by religion and social structure (Abrams, 1999). The Bible decreed the ‘natural order’ that was accepted by the population, and people generally accepted their place in society. Social classes were divided into several layers. The highest social standing was still nobility. Below the nobility were religious leaders. Yeomen were middle to large farmers freely holding their own land and wealth. Husbandmen were small farmers working on rented land and often holding second jobs as laborers. Day laborers made up most of the population, and females in domestic positions consisted of two thirds of this group. Sercants in husbandry were employed by masters or mistresses typically to do manual labor. At the lowest end of the social ranking were the poor and beggars. Although 70% of the population were husbandry or below in social status this was considered acceptable (Abrams, 1999). The nobility and gentry held power over the majority. It was possible to move upward in social class but was more likely to drop downward because of injury, illness, poor crops, or widowhood.
Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night”
William Shakespeare wrote his play “Twelfth Night” as a comedic view of love, deceit, revenge, and social order. The story follows the protagonist Viola who after being rescued from a sea wreck assumes the identity of her brother to gain employment. She goes to work for Orsino the duke of Illyria and falls in love with him. This is obviously complicated since she is disguised as a man. The situation gets further complicated as Orsino sends Viola, disguised as Cesario, to woo Olivia a countess that whom Orsino loves. Olivia has no interest in Orsino and becomes enamored with Cesario. Beyond this love triangle is Sir Andrew and Malvolio who each desire to win Olivia as his wife; Maria, Olivia’s servant woman, who is in love with Sir Toby, Olivia’s uncle; Antonio the sea captain who is in love with Viola’s brother Sebastian; and the re-emergence of Sebastian to the town of Illyria confusing everyone and revealing Viola’s true identity. Each character’s social standing present bearing on the capability to obtain his or her desires.
Character Desires in “Twelfth Night”
The characters of Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” have unique longings that will them to behave a particular way to obtain their desires.
Viola desired to obtain employment following the shipwreck so she disguises herself as a man. This is significant because she could not gain employment because of her gender. By posing as a man Viola earns respect and a place working directly for the duke. While posing as the man Cesario Viola falls in love with the duke. She desires his love in return, but he has feelings for the countess Olivia. This is significant because he does not really know the countess and most likely chose her for her beauty and position. Still he claims undying love for Olivia. For Viola to achieve her desire she must follow the wishes of Orsino as her master and find some way to foil the connection between him and Olivia. She mentions this problem “I'll do my best To woo your lady: aside yet, a barful strife! Whoe'er I woo, myself would be his wife” (1.4.7) This proves little problem since Olivia is not interested in Orsino. Viola also desires that her emotions and intelligence be accepted despite gender stereotype that Orsino believes. Finally, Viola desires to be reunited with her brother who she loves and believes to be lost at sea.
Orsino and Olivia
Orsino, the duke of Illyria, desires the love of Olivia, but Olivia does not return his love. To obtain his desire Orsino sends Viola, disguised as Cesario, to win the heart of Olivia. During the first visit Olivia falls in love with Cesario. She desires this suitor who understands her and speaks to her with such poetic language, and not Orsino who she believes knows nothing about her. Cesario does not desire Olivia because she is actually a woman, and in love with Orsino.
Malvolio is Olivia’s steward. He mistreats his coworkers and desires to win Olivia’s hand in marriage to gain higher social standing. In the play he mentions how another servant advanced through marriage “There is example for't; the lady of the Strachy married the yeoman of the wardrobe” (2.5.2). This desire for advancements breeds resentment from his peers who desire revenge upon Malvolio. They achieve this be giving him a false letter proclaiming love from Olivia. He is made to look foolish, and Olivia believes that he has gone mad. He is locked up for this madness.
This man is a friend to Sir Toby, Olivia’s uncle, Sir Andrew desires Olivia for himself. Although he tries to portray himself as brave and worthy of Olivia he is perceived as a fool by his peers and Olivia does not desire him. Despite this Sir Toby makes a plea for his worth “She'll none o' the count: she'll not match above her degree, neither in estate, years, nor wit; I have heard her swear't. Tut, there's life in't, man” (1.3.21)
Maria and Sir Toby
Maria is Olivia’s waiting-gentlewoman. She is of lower class breeding and her language and actions provide insight into her social class, “what a caterwauling do you keep here” (2.3.68). Still she is in love with Sir Toby, Olivia’s uncle. Despite their difference in social roles Sir Toby marries her for her cunning in tricking Malvolio.
Feste is the jester, singer, and entertainer of the play. He is regarded as a fool. He plays a role in tricking Malvolio and also setting him free. He interacts with all the characters in various ways which reveal that he is not a fool at all, and may in fact be the most intelligent of the crew. His desire varies. He wishes to go unseen among the people, so he acts the part of the fool which is expected of him. He desires attention, which his antics bring him. Besides these obvious desires that his actions reward him with, he appears to have a deeper desire to be recognized for his own intelligence and ability. He gains his own revenge on Malvolio quoting Malvolio’s insults of him “Madam, why laugh you ad such a barren a rascal, an you smile not, he’s gagged- and this the whirligig of time brings in his revenges” (5.1.371).
Sebastian and Antonio
Sebastian is Viola’s brother who is rescued by Antonio. Antonio falls in love the Sebastian which goes against the gender roles and Christian models of the period. Antonio follows Sebastian into Illyria although he it is dangerous for him “I could not stay behind you: my desire, More sharp than filed steel, did spur me forth; And not all love to see you” (3.3.1). Sebastian goes about town and discovers Olivia. She mistakes him for Cesario and leads him off to marry her. He falls in love with her immediately and the two are married. His desire is acceptance, love, and understanding of the bizarre situation. Antonio does not win his desire and leaves without Sebastian.
Relation of Character’s Desire to Reality
The characters in Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” offer interesting representations of desires that would be expected among 16th century people.
Her desire for equality would be shared by many women of the day. Olivia even points out how Orsino could not truly love her without knowing her. Women were not respected and seen as feeble-minded. Viola’s interactions as a man revealed that Shakespeare recognized that the genders were not so very different. Also, Viola’s love of Orsino would be commonplace. Love is a desire that all people have. Her particular love for Orsino may represent the desire to advance in social status because even though Orsino loved someone else and believed women to be inferior Viola still was enamored with him. This may have been for his position as well as his personality.
His desire for Olivia presents the 16th century reality of nobility marrying one another. The social classes often stayed together, so Olivia would have been viewed as an acceptable choice for Orsino’s wife.
Her desire for Cesario may have presented the reality of women hoping to be accepted for their own intelligence. She did not desire Orsino, who would have been considered a good match for her in that period. She chose someone who recognized her own merit. This represents the increased appeal of education and change of the time.
Malvolio, Maria, and Sir Andrew
Each of these characters present desires that advance their role in society. Malvolio’s desire represents the reality of the desire for social advancement. Maria may have desired social advancement from her position as Olivia’s servant. Sir Andrew’s desire represents the need to be viewed with esteem by his peers as well as the desire for love
Sir Toby presents a character that fits the reality of the times well. Of higher social class he found himself with increased time, and with boredom chose several avenues. He teases and torments his friend Sir Andrew, he takes part in the revenge against Malvolio, and he consumes vast amounts of alcohol which was a common problem of the period as hard liquor became more readily available (Ianuzzo, n.d.). Sir Toby’s desire reflects the changing roles of the advancing middle class and how they dealt with the shift in social rank.
Influences on Language
The language used in Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night” offers interesting perspective into how language affects life. The poetic language used in wooing Olivia, and Viola’s attempts to persuade Orsino of the merits of women present intoxicating rhythm and manipulation of emotion. The beauty of the language ties with the beauty of romance, with the desired goal of winning those who listen. Metaphor and imagery allow the poetic language to provide the listener with mental pictures of the hope and beauty that love can bring. Viola uses metaphor and imagery in wooing Olivia for Orsino “Make me a willow cabin at your gate, And call upon my soul within the house; Write loyal cantons of contemned love And sing them loud even in the dead of night” (1.5.19).
Another example of language used to shift meaning in this play is the bawdy dialect used by the servants, Sir Andrew, and Sir Toby. Their language is raucous and rough giving the example of working class people. Their wording is to the point, yet provides merry entertainment of their shenanigans against one another. Feste points out his own simple work “I am indeed not her fool, but her corrupter of words” (3.1.8). The incorporation of silly songs ties the raucous dialect and hidden agendas together.
All people have desires. Some desire love, position, advancement, or acceptance. The desires are often shaped by society. When society represses people they desire to move beyond this oppression. Shakespeare’s play presents an interesting blend of characters who playfully represent the desires of 16th century people. Each character has his or her own motivation, but they all reflect the people of the time. Literature is often a reflection of reality. The language of the play offers poetic beauty and realistic common dialect. The blend provides readers and viewers with a fascinating perspective of 16th century life.
Abrams, A. (1999). Social structure in the 16th century. Retrieved from http://www.tudorgroup.co.uk/articles/social_structure.html
Greenblatt, S. & Abrams, M.H. (2006). Greenblatt, S. & Abrams, M.H. (2006). The norton anthology of English literature. (8th ed.). New York, NY:W.W. Norton & Company.
Ianuzzo, C.T. (n.d.). The sixteenth century. Retrieved from http://lepg.org/sixteen.htm
Shakespeare, W. (2006). Twelfth night. The norton anthology of English literature. (8th ed.). New York, NY:W.W. Norton & Company.